Moral Dilemmas in Real Life / Law and Philosophy Library Bd.74 (PDF)

Ovadia Ezra neither offers a polemic on moral issues, nor presents a collection of snippets from the writings of moral philosophers. Instead, in Moral Dilemmas in Real Life, Ezra dives directly into specific social and ethical issues, outlines the moral parameters and essential questions that are highlighted by such issues, makes recommendations regarding the moral theories and ethical epistemologies that are likely to offer helpful insights in each case, and charges the reader with the responsibility of completing the analysis and are arriving at practical conclusions. In so doing, Ezra draws from a rich supply of philosophers, ethicists, jurists, and social scientists (whose works, in turn, are referenced in several hundred footnotes).

One of the issues addressed by Ezra is the right of privacy. The author draws from legal precepts, virtue theory, and the insights of various social philosophers in an effort to show the nuances and limitations of the concept. Several specific circumstances, wherein the right to privacy is at issue, are described: questions about the protection of the identity of suspects who are under investigation for a crime (but who have not been charged with a crime); the protection of the medical records, especially of celebrities, artists, politicians, professional athletes, etc.; and gag orders protecting the identity of convicted juvenile offenders who have arrived at the age of majority. Each of these cases are addressed from the perspective of various normative theories, and each are explored in light of judicial pronouncements, the observations of social commentators, and the insights of various social critics.

Separately, Ezra considers the right to "be let alone." That is, the right to live and work without being unnecessarily confronted or encumbered by, or intruded upon, by government (despite the need of law enforcement agencies to ensure safety and security in an increasingly dangerous world). To flesh out this dilemma, the author selects to interesting cases: proposed legislation requiring Internet service providers to retain records -- including contents -- of e-mails and Internet transmissions for a period of seven years; and, the expansion of DNA information banks beyond the immediate needs of law enforcement and medical databases. Both of these cases, and the analyses provided by the author, and help the reader to appreciate the enlarging the scope of both technology and the resultant ethical issues.

Other issues, approached in the same manner, include freedom of expression in academia and the media, mercy killing, the selling of human organs, genetic engineering and reproduction, "parental" rights of relatives and generations, procreation after death, babies as commodities, punishment of sex offenders and those who engage in domestic violence, and capital punishment (especially in regard to the mentally disabled). For each of these dilemmas, the author offers well-researched insights, specific cases, and suggestions that prompt the reader to think carefully and critically about the underlying moral questions.

Even though this book is scholarly and intellectually uncompromising, it is accessible by most readers. In part, this is because the book is written in a style that is pleasant, engaging, and inviting. And it is also because, as Ezra puts it, "any thinking person is required, so it seems, to be concerned, involved, or--at the very least--conversant with the ins and outs of ethical argument." (p. ix) The moral dilemmas presented by Ezra are selected and sifted for the edification of any "thinking person" who would wish to begin a journey toward an understanding of well-informed applied ethics."

© 2007 Albert D. Spalding

Albert D. Spalding, JD, is an associate professor at Wayne State University School of Business Administration. He teaches legal studies and ethics.